I met with a new client in my office the other day, he presented to me a Notice of Intent to Rescind his status by USCIS. The Service alleges that he is subject to rescission, because he was not living together with his wife at the time of the adjustment interview, and that he had lied about their living arrangements to the interviewing USCIS officer. What can one do in this situation?
The first analysis that comes to mind is Matter of McKee, 17 I & N Dec. 332 (BIA 1980). In Matter of McKee the Board of Appeals held that a visa petition could be approved, even though the parties had separated and the marriage was no longer viable, as long as the marriage was bona fide at inception, and had not been terminated. This is a key point even today and many USCIS officers seems to ignore this concept.
In another case, Matter of Boromand, 17 I&N. Dec. 2811 (BIA 1980), The Board reviewed the evidence and concluded that it did “not appear that the respondent married” his United States citizen wife for the “sole purpose of evading the immigration laws. Based on this finding, the Board concluded that the adjustment could not be rescinded, based on the charge that he had materially misrepresented his living arrangements with his wife at the time of the adjustment interview.