Due to COVID-19, we are providing calls via PHONE or VIDEO conferencing for your safety.

Please call us 619.819.9204 we are here for YOU! READ MORE

When Marrying Too Soon Isn’t Such a Good Idea – Issues with Preconceived Intent in Adjustment of Status Context

6168801346_55ea65baac_z

By Ekaterina Powell, Esq.

Getting married is an important step in everyone’s life.  For some, it is a well-planned event. For others, it is a spontaneous decision. However, for those foreign nationals who are coming to the U.S. to marry U.S. citizens, it needs to be a very thought-through decision because if they marry too fast, it can result in big problems at the time they apply for the green card.

Whenever you come to the U.S. as a visitor, you represent to the immigration officer at the time of visa application and at the port of entry that you do not intend to reside in the U.S. permanently and that you intend to depart the U.S. after a short-term visit. Even if you are not asked a specific question by a consular officer or customers and border agent at the port of entry on whether you want to stay in the U.S., by way of coming into the U.S. with a nonimmigrant visa you show your nonimmigrant intent.

Marrying a U.S. citizen soon after entry into the U.S. and applying for a green card is inconsistent with the representations you made to the consular officer and to the customs and border agent concerning your intent in coming to the U.S. Thus, if you marry a U.S. citizen soon after coming to the U.S., you may be found to have a preconceived intent to immigrate, which may then cause problems at the time you apply for the green card.

So, how does USCIS determine whether there was a preconceived intent to immigrate and what are the consequences?

To address the problem with the preconceived intent and to determine when the foreign national’s actions within the U.S. are inconsistent with the nonimmigrant representations, resulting in the charge of misrepresentation, the Department of State has developed the so-called “30/60-day” rule designed for the consular posts but often followed by USCIS in adjudication of green card applications. See 9 FAM 40.63, Note 4.7, Interpretation of the Term “Misrepresentation”, Applying the 30/60 Day Rule.

 Department of State’s 30/60 Rule

 Actions within 30 days of entry

Under the rule, if you violate your nonimmigrant status or engage in other actions incompatible with your nonimmigrant intent (including for example marrying and applying for a green card) within 30 days of entry, it may be presumed that you have misrepresented your nonimmigrant intention in seeking a visa or entry. See 9 FAM 40.63 N4.7-2

Actions more than 30 days but less than 60 days after entry

If the actions inconsistent with the manner of entry occur more than 30 days but less than 60 days after entry into the U.S., there is a rebuttable presumption of misrepresentation. In that case, countervailing evidence may be presented by the foreign national to show that there was no intent to misrepresent. If the consulate is not persuaded, the foreign national may seek an advisory opinion from DOS. See 9 FAM 40.63 N4.7-3

Actions more than 60 days after entry

If the actions occur more than 60 days after entry into the United States, it does not raise the misrepresentation or preconceived intent concerns. See 9 FAM 40.63 N4.7-4

 

Preconceived Intent to Remain in the U.S. in Adjudication of Adjustment of Status

Foreign national seeking adjustment of status must be able to show that there was no immigrant intent at the time of nonimmigrant visa application or entry into the U.S.

It is worth noting that 30/60 rule is the DOS rule applied by consular posts at the time of visa issuance. USCIS does not contain similar provisions but in practice USCIS tends to use this rule as guidance during adjudication of adjustment of status application when there is an issue with the preconceived intent or misrepresentation. You should keep this rule in mind before you decide to apply for adjustment of status in the U.S.

The decision on granting adjustment of status to permanent resident (green card) is discretionary in nature. See AFM 23.2(d).

In context of a preconceived intent to immigrate, especially if there are any other adverse factors present, USCIS may find that favorable exercise of discretion is not warranted, thus denying the adjustment of status.

USCIS Adjudicator’s Field Manual in sections 23.2(d), Exercise of discretion and 23.5(p)(6), Precedent Decisions specifically references the following case law on point:

  • Matter of Garcia-Castillo, 10 I&N Dec. 516 (BIA, 1964). Entry as a nonimmigrant with a preconceived intention to remain is a serious adverse factor to be considered.
  • Matter of Ro, 16 I&N Dec. 93 (BIA 1977), A preconceived intent to remain permanently at time of arrival as a nonimmigrant where foreign national applied for adjustment of status within 16 days of entry into the U.S. was found to be sufficient reason to deny an adjustment application as a matter of discretion despite existence of favorable factors.
  • Matter of Baltazar, 16 I&N Dec. 108 (BIA, 1977). An application for adjustment was denied as a matter of discretion where the judge concluded that the applicant had (1) divorced his spouse in order to obtain immigration benefits and (2) entered the U.S. as a nonimmigrant with a preconceived intent to remain permanently.
  • Matter of Cavazos, 17 I&N Dec. 215 (BIA, 1980). In the absence of other adverse factors, an application for adjustment by an immediate relative should generally be granted in the exercise of discretion notwithstanding the fact that the applicant entered as a nonimmigrant with a preconceived intention to remain.
  • Matter of Ibrahim, 18 I&N Dec. 55 (BIA, 1981). The benefits of Matter of Cavazos, supra, are limited to immediate relatives, and an application for adjustment by a fifth preference immigrant with a preconceived intention to remain is properly denied in the exercise of discretion.

At the time USCIS adjudicates your adjustment of status (green card) application, the immigration officer may inquire further into the manner you came into the U.S. and the circumstances surrounding your sudden marriage. If the immigration officer believes that you intended to immigrate at the time you entered the U.S., it means that you have misrepresented your intentions and USCIS may use its discretion in either denying adjustment of status or asking to submit a waiver.

One of the ways to prove your nonimmigrant intent is to show overwhelming evidence that you did not want to immigrate to the U.S. at the time of visa application or entry and that your intent was formed after you came to the U.S.

Helpful evidence to show your nonimmigrant intent includes documentation proving ties with your home country, which you had no intention to abandon. You can provide your employment records showing that you have a job back home, lease agreements or mortgage documents showing existence of property back home, evidence of foreign assets, school records, evidence of foreign debts, bank accounts, or any other proof that you intended to return to your home country after a short trip to the U.S.

You can show that you did not have the intent to remain in the U.S. when you entered but the circumstances have changed and you have formed the intent thereafter while already in the U.S. For example, if you married soon after entry, you can show correspondence between you and your spouse, receipts for the ring you purchased already in the U.S., affidavits from family members, pictures from your proposal, etc. as evidence that you formed the intent to marry after coming to the U.S.

If the immigration officer finds that you had a preconceived intent to remain in the U.S. and misrepresented yourself, you may be required to file a waiver of inadmissibility, referred to as “I-601 waiver,” by which you would need to show extreme hardship to your U.S. citizen or Lawful Permanent Resident spouse or parent. This process is designed to waive many grounds of inadmissibility including misrepresentation ground if there is extreme hardship to a qualifying relative. If the waiver is approved, immigration officer will proceed with the adjudication of your green card case.

Adjustment of Status to permanent resident is an important step and should not be taken lightly. Before you decide to get married and apply for the green card, talk to an immigration attorney to discuss any concerns.